|Anonymous | Login||2021-04-15 14:52 UTC|
|Main | My View | View Issues | Change Log | Docs|
|Viewing Issue Simple Details|
|ID||Category||Severity||Type||Date Submitted||Last Update|
|0001437||[1003.1(2016/18)/Issue7+TC2] Shell and Utilities||Editorial||Enhancement Request||2020-12-15 21:02||2020-12-17 21:16|
|Section||Vol. 3: Shell and Utilities, Issue 7, make|
|Page Number||(2975) 2989|
|Line Number||(98708, 98742) 99308|
|Final Accepted Text|
|Summary||0001437: make: (document .NOTPARALLEL and .WAIT special targets) in RATIONAL|
Parallel, even massively parallel processing has become the widely supported and
used default, yet the standard make(1) does not document it.
If the -j command line option as requested in issue #1436 is standardized,
the standard should also mention ways to synchronize rule processing, in order
to support more complicated build relationships seen in real-life projects.
The suggestion given here can be used with the most widely used make(1)
implementations (GNU make, BSD make) on any tested platform (Linux, *BSD, SunOS
The make family rooted on the Sun side of likfe has has at least .WAIT: reserved
for decades, and in practice
.WAIT: # Luckily BSD make supports specifying this as target, too
tangerine: config .WAIT build .WAIT test .WAIT install
citron: config .WAIT build .WAIT install
all: config .WAIT build
produces the desired outcome.
On page 2975, insert before line 98708
When specified all rules specified in the given makefile are processed
sequentially, as if -j has not been given.
On page 2975, insert before line 98472
When .WAIT appears in a dependency line, prerequisites that appear after it
are built no sooner until all preceeding prerequisites have been built
On page 2975, change on line 98472 ff.
The special targets .IGNORE, .POSIX, .PRECIOUS, .SILENT, and .SUFFIXES shall
be specified without commands.
The special targets .IGNORE, .NOTPARALLEL, .POSIX, .PRECIOUS, .SILENT,
.SUFFIXES and .WAIT shall be specified without commands.
On page 2989, insert before line 99308
The special targets .NOTPARALLEL and .WAIT represent different, rather
incompatible synchronisation concepts of parallel build environments as
used by the diverse implementations. By using an indirection both approaches
can be supported: for implementations which use .NOTPARALLEL in a makefile to
ensure sequential rule processing in the given file the full power of parallel
processing will be available in recursive make instances invoked on makefiles
without the directive, implementations which synchronize on the .WAIT special
target will synchronize on it, for example:
.NOTPARALLEL: # Process all rules sequentially
.WAIT: # Define to satisfy "the other implementation"
install: config .WAIT all
all: config .WAIT build
make -f makefile.build
|Tags||No tags attached.|
|Just to note, GNU make does not support the .WAIT special target.|
Ach! I wish it would, i think the .WAIT approach "is better" (as in explicit, and does not need an indirection).
But you said on the ML that you do not plan to support it either.
This is why the first part above is in parenthesis, and this issue actually requests some words in RATIONALE instead.
The presented solution has the desired effect also in GNU make ("build" target uses parallel processing).
I don't believe I said I didn't want GNU make to support it; I agree that it seems like a useful feature. I just said that given the way make's parallel support works I suspect implementation is not so easy and I didn't plan to work on it as I have other things on my (relatively small) plate.
But, if someone else were to get motivated to try to get this working that would be fine with me :). I wonder if creating some kind of internal/implicit prerequisite relationship that wasn't visible to users would be a simpler way to implement this... or not. Well, something for someone to consider.
|2020-12-15 21:02||steffen||New Issue|
|2020-12-15 21:02||steffen||Name||=> steffen|
|2020-12-15 21:02||steffen||Section||=> Vol. 3: Shell and Utilities, Issue 7, make|
|2020-12-15 21:02||steffen||Page Number||=> (2975) 2989|
|2020-12-15 21:02||steffen||Line Number||=> (98708, 98742) 99308|
|2020-12-17 17:10||psmith||Note Added: 0005184|
|2020-12-17 19:23||steffen||Note Added: 0005185|
|2020-12-17 21:16||psmith||Note Added: 0005186|
|Mantis 1.1.6[^] Copyright © 2000 - 2008 Mantis Group|